This tasteful, modern house with gorgeous views of Shelter Island Sound sits on 200 feet of beachfront property. Four rooms with private baths are for rent. To discourage walk-in business, the proprietor does not list a street address. $$$-$$$$ more...
Overlooking a wide creek, this country home near a handful of shops has been handsomely restored. There are four antique-filled guest rooms, each with a private bath. A continental breakfast is served on a sun porch. $$-$$$$ more...
This renovated farmhouse, formerly the Olde Country Inn, is attractive and very comfortable. The owners say they have added "a modern beach chic twist that embraces the classic charm" of the late 1800s house. Many of the well-appointed eight guest rooms are spacious, and all have private baths. There is indoor and outdoor dining, a lounge bar and an outdoor bar in the garden. A bakery bakes fresh bread and muffins daily. $$$-$$$$ more...
This attractive 17-room center-hall colonial inn offering fine dining sits on a hill above Coecles Harbor. Rates include a buffet breakfast and use of boats, a beach and a tennis court. $-$$$ more...
Owned by the proprietors of the Ram's Head Inn, this restored Victorian inn with a covered veranda stands tall on a quiet main street. You can walk to shops and are close to the North Ferry. All 35 guest rooms in the inn and two adjacent cottages have private baths. Guests may use the Ram's Head Inn's tennis court, fitness center and private beach. $$-$$$$ more...